source: https://xkcd.com/125/
If you've been building your online brand on Twitter, you're probably familiar with the frustration of putting in hours of effort, only to see little in return. You’ve been posting great content, writing a few direct messages (DMs) here and there, but when it comes to making sales, it feels like you're hitting a wall.
You’re not alone in this struggle. Many creators and entrepreneurs face the same problem. They focus on pushing out content but forget a crucial piece of the puzzle: the psychology behind building relationships and converting cold DMs into sales.
So, let’s break it down. By the end of this article, you’ll not only understand how cold DMs can be a powerful tool, but you'll also learn the psychology that makes them effective. With this knowledge, you’ll be better equipped to connect with potential clients, build meaningful relationships, and, yes, make sales.
Table of Contents
- 1. Why Cold DMs Work (When Done Right)
- 2. The Psychology Behind Building Trust
- 3. Getting Into Your Prospect's Mindset
- 4. How to Craft a DM That Gets a Response
- 5. The 4-Step Framework for Effective Cold DMs
- 6. Overcoming Objections in Cold DMs
- 7. The Importance of Follow-Up
- 8. Avoiding Common Cold DM Mistakes
- 9. Conclusion: Cold DMs as a Relationship-Building Tool
1. Why Cold DMs Work (When Done Right)
Cold DMs often get a bad reputation, mostly because many people use them in the wrong way. If you think about it, how many times have you received a cold DM and immediately turned away annoyed because it felt spammy or disingenuous?
But here’s the truth: Cold DMs can work—when done correctly. The key lies in the approach. A well-crafted DM taps into human psychology. It’s not about forcing a sale but about building a connection and positioning yourself as someone who can solve a problem.
If your DMs aren’t working, it’s not because the strategy is flawed. It’s because the execution is off. You need to understand what motivates people, what triggers trust, and how to communicate value in a way that feels natural and authentic.
2. The Psychology Behind Building Trust
Trust is everything. Without it, people won’t buy from you. It’s as simple as that. But how do you build trust with someone you’ve never met?
a) The Role of Reciprocity
Ever notice how you feel inclined to do something for someone when they’ve done something for you? This is called reciprocity, a powerful psychological principle that can work in your favor when building trust.
When you provide value upfront—whether that’s helpful advice, a relevant resource, your free lead magnet or simply acknowledging their work—it creates a sense of obligation. The person is more likely to reciprocate by responding to your DM, engaging with your content, or considering your offer down the road.
b) Consistency and Authenticity
People trust those who are consistent and authentic. If your DMs feel overly scripted or pushy, they’ll immediately turn people off. However, if you stay true to your voice, your mission, and your values, people will feel a genuine connection to you.
3. Getting Into Your Prospect's Mindset
Before you send a cold DM, you need to think like your prospect. Imagine you’re in their shoes. What are they currently struggling with? What are their goals, pain points, or fears?
Here’s how to get into their mindset:
- Research their profile. Take a few minutes to check out their Twitter feed. What topics are they talking about? What content are they engaging with? This gives you clues about their interests and challenges.
- Engage with their content first. Before sending a DM, try liking, retweeting, or commenting on their posts. This establishes familiarity and can make your eventual message feel less “cold.”
Engaging with their content first can be systematized easily so that you don't get overwhelmed: put every potential prospect on a twitter list and engage with them daily. This is your so called "dream 100" list. If you pick accounts that don't have buzz, you'll be seen immediately. This step can even be automated.
When you understand your prospect’s mindset, your DMs become much more targeted and relevant. And that brings us to the next point...
4. How to Craft a DM That Gets a Response
Now, let’s talk about the actual content of your cold DMs. A successful cold DM isn’t about pitching your product right away. It’s about initiating a conversation that eventually leads to a sale.
a) Personalization
Avoid cookie-cutter messages at all costs. Personalization shows that you’ve taken the time to get to know the person you're messaging. Mention something specific from their profile or a recent tweet. For example:
“Hey [Name], I saw your tweet about [topic], and it really resonated with me because [reason]. I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately and would love to hear your thoughts.”
Personalized messages immediately stand out and signal that you’re not just another random person trying to sell something.
b) Focus on Them, Not You
One of the biggest mistakes people make in cold DMs is focusing too much on themselves. Instead of leading with what you offer, lead with how you can help the person.
A good rule of thumb: Your first DM should never be about making a sale. It should be about starting a conversation. Offer help, ask for their opinion, or provide value with no strings attached.
“I noticed you mentioned struggling with [problem] in your tweet. I’ve been working with clients on similar challenges. If you’re open to it, I’d be happy to share a few insights that might help.”
c) Keep It Short and Sweet
People on Twitter are used to consuming short bursts of information. Your DM should reflect that. Get straight to the point, but keep it casual and conversational.
5. The 4-Step Framework for Effective Cold DMs
To simplify the process, here’s a 4-step framework you can use to structure your cold DMs:
Step 1: Warm-Up
Before you DM, engage with their content. Like or retweet their posts to create awareness and familiarity. This makes your DM less “cold.”
Step 2: Personalized Intro
Start the DM with something specific to the person, like mentioning a recent tweet or their profile. This shows you’ve done your homework and aren’t sending a mass message.
Step 3: Provide Value
Offer something valuable—whether it’s advice, a solution to their problem, or just genuine interest in what they’re doing. You want to position yourself as someone who can help, not just someone who’s selling.
Step 4: Soft Call to Action
Don’t be pushy, but give them an opportunity to engage. This can be as simple as asking for their opinion or offering to chat further.
“I’d love to hear more about your experience with [challenge]. If you ever want to chat about it, feel free to reach out!”
6. Overcoming Objections in Cold DMs
If you’ve ever sent cold DMs, you’ve likely faced objections. Sometimes people respond, but they’re hesitant to move forward. That’s okay—objections are natural. Your goal is to handle them tactfully without being pushy.
a) “I don’t have time.”
Respond with empathy. Acknowledge their busy schedule and offer a quick, low-commitment solution. For example:
“Totally get it! I know time is valuable. If you want, I can share a brief overview in this DM—just let me know if you’re interested.”
b) “I’m not sure I need this.”
Instead of pushing back, ask questions to better understand their needs. This allows you to tailor your response and show how your offer could benefit them specifically.
“Totally understand. Out of curiosity, what’s the biggest challenge you’re facing in [topic]? I might be able to help, even if it’s just offering some advice.”
7. The Importance of Follow-Up
One of the most overlooked aspects of cold DMs is the follow-up. People are busy, and it’s easy for them to miss or forget your message. A polite, well-timed follow-up can be the difference between getting ignored and getting a response.
Tips for effective follow-ups:
- Wait at least 48-72 hours before following up.
- Keep it casual and light. Something like:
“Hey [Name], just wanted to bump this up in case it got buried in your messages!”
- Follow up no more than two or three times. If they don’t respond after that, move on.
8. Avoiding Common Cold DM Mistakes
Here are some common mistakes that can kill your chances of getting a response:
a) Being Too Pushy
Don’t try to make the sale in the first DM. Focus on building rapport first.
b) Writing Long Paragraphs
Keep your message concise. Twitter is a fast-paced platform, and long messages will likely get skipped over.
c) Not Personalizing Your Message
Generic messages are easy to spot and are almost always ignored. Personalize each DM to show you’ve done your research.
d) Skipping the Follow-Up
Don’t assume silence means disinterest. Many people miss messages. A friendly follow-up can reopen the conversation.
9. Conclusion: Cold DMs as a Relationship-Building Tool
Cold DMs on Twitter can be an incredibly effective way to build relationships and convert leads into sales. But the key to success lies in understanding the psychology behind it. It’s not just about pushing out a sales pitch—it’s about engaging with people in a way that feels authentic, helpful, and human.
When you approach cold DMs with the goal of building trust and providing value, you’ll find that sales happen naturally. By following the strategies outlined in this article, you can turn your DMs from cold to warm, and ultimately, into sales.
Every DM is an opportunity to start a conversation. And as with any relationship, it’s the small, consistent efforts that eventually lead to big results. So next time you send a cold DM, think of it as the first step in a meaningful dialogue, not just a transaction.
Good luck!
And if you'd like to put your cold DM outreach on autopilot to focus on other important tasks in your business (or to have a life)
Try this (click here)